A reflection by Monsignor Peter Fleetwood focusing on what it is that makes people
view practising Catholics as hypocrites:
" As a priest , I hear a variety
of reasons for not going to church. Some are convincing, but most are not. The most
common reason people give in my home country is this: "I don't bother going to church,
Father . It's not worth it, because the place is full of hypocrites ". The clever
answer is to say "One more will make no difference, so why not come and join us?"
Beyond clever answers , though, what is it that makes people view practising Catholics
as hypocrites? Various famous people have given eloquent answers. Mahatma Gandhi admired
Jesus Christ, but thought Christians seemed to fail miserably at putting into practice
the values Jesus taught. Just a hundred years ago a man died after writing some bitter
criticisms of Christianity: he was Friedrich Nietzsche, the philologist and philosopher
whose sombre Lutheran childhood had convinced him that Christianity ought to have
liberated people, but in fact made them miserable and mean-minded.
To see what
he meant, look at the faces of people coming out of church on a Sunday. In some places
people rush out of church as soon as they can , even before the liturgy has ended
; they just can't wait to get away. It obviously depends on many things, but where
a community really knows how to celebrate faith , people gather and talk and greet
their friends . They are clearly very happy to be part of a community where they
find support and life. Their attendance at church is something which recharges their
spiritual batteries and gives them the energy to make a difference to their world
during the week ahead.
But there is more to this idea that churches are full
of hypocrites. It is the accusation that people who go regularly to church claim to
believe in the Gospel, but live by completely different standards. It means that those
people are one thing on a Sunday , and quite the opposite for the rest of the week.
We have to listen and take this seriously, because, even if it is not absolutely
true, this is how Christians come across to some people. Jesus was the first to point
out that his real followers would be recognisable by their fruits , in other words
by the difference their faith made to the way they lived. And the Christians in Antioch
were given that name because the way they lived proved they were striving to follow
Christ's command : "love one another , the way I loved you "...
Listen to Monsigno
Peter's full reflection in what is part of the series "Why Bother? Staying Catholic
despite it all...", produced by Veronica Scarisbrick.